In the last few months, the world has watched in horror and confusion as countries, both large and small, around the world have moved to ban the popular short-form video-sharing app, TikTok. A variety of conspiracy theories have been flung back and forth, with some claiming that the bans are a result of external meddling, while others have argued that the bans are justified given concerns over data privacy and security issues. However, these arguments overlook one simple fact: banning TikTok is dumb.
First and foremost, it’s important to remember that banning a popular, widely-used form of communication is never a wise move. Beyond just the ethical implications, these bans restrict the flow of information and the ability of individuals to connect with anyone they want. The end result is a silencing of voices and a less transparent, more opaque method of communication that can often be abused.
The other issue is that bans are rarely effective. As we have seen in China, where the social media-heavy WeChat and Weibo remain freely available to use despite the country’s ban on TikTok, there are always workarounds. Moreover, the ban is only a short-term solution, with most of the world’s more tech-savvy population likely to find a way around the ban and continue to use the app illegally.
Finally, the sheer reception and popularity of TikTok suggest that there are many benefits to be had from its use. The app has made it easier to express yourself, stay connected, and even to make money through creative projects. Banning TikTok takes this all away, hindering creativity and connection, stifling expression, and limiting access to opportunities for global citizens.
Ultimately, there are undeniable issues with data privacy and security that need to be addressed. But banning TikTok outright is a clumsy and inadequate solution to a much more complex problem. It is simply not the answer, and should not be regarded as a viable solution moving forward.
